Comparing Employee Assessments: DiSC® and the HBDI®

Choosing the right employee assessment for your team or organization can be confusing. Many instruments overlap in what they measure and in how they’re used. So, we’re kicking off a new blog series to compare those different assessments and dive into how you might use them to achieve your business and talent development needs. This series is written by Anne Griswold, our Whole Brain ® Thinking Catalyst. Anne has been a facilitator, trainer and coach for over 20 years, working both inside companies and as an independent consultant. She is certified in many assessment tools and leadership trainings programs, including the HBDI, MBTI, DiSC, Hogan, Firo-B, EI 2.0 and Franklin-Covey Training Programs.

First up: Anne takes a closer look at the DiSC assessment and how it compares with Whole Brain Thinking and the HBDI.

DiSC is a popular employee assessment that is a good tool for understanding different styles, behaviors and perspectives of ourselves, of other people and how we respond in different situations. Like the HBDI, it’s a four-factor model, but in the case of DiSC, each color-coded letter represents a behavior trait: D for Dominance, i for Influence, S for Steadiness and C for Conscientiousness. Unlike the HBDI—which has a brain-based premise that considers, “How do I process information?”—DiSC is a behavior-based assessment that considers, “How do I behave in a specific situation and how do others perceive me?” DiSC, like most assessments, gives us insight. Those insights are focused on the impact of the individual’s behavior.

Because it helps people see the diversity of behaviors in those around them, the DiSC assessment can be a nice conversation starter and a helpful tool for people who’ve never had the opportunity to do much reflection at all.

With their DiSC Profile, people can confirm, “This is a style of mine and this is how my behavior impacts others.” They can quickly observe and evaluate the specific DiSC traits in themselves and in those around them. I’ll often use DiSC as an entry level assessment for organizations that haven’t used employee assessments before. It’s a good tool to introduce learning about different styles for a bootcamp supervisory or management program and for work in teams. Another plus is the tool’s ability to account for context, environment, function and team dynamics. With these features, the DiSC Profile can present a more contextually nuanced picture of the person’s behavior than some other personality or behavior assessments can.

From a facilitator’s standpoint, DiSC is easy to administer. The self-paced design requires only minimal facilitation, and its flexibility and lower price point are attractive to companies that have immediate or short-term needs and aren’t necessarily interested in broader strategic impact. If you need to do a quick tactical rollout to “wake people up” to differences in behavioral style and give them a way to talk about those behaviors, then DiSC can serve your needs.

Similarities and Differences Between DiSC and the HBDI

As mentioned, the two assessments have different premises, so they look at different things. Instead of focusing on behaviors, the HBDI provides insight into thinking preferences, which may or may not inform someone’s behavior. Thinking preferences also influence how people communicate, make decisions, problem solve and innovate.

The uses, purposes and outcomes are often different as well. In general, the lifespan and long-term impact of a DiSC implementation is limited to learning more about self, others and teams. Beyond that, it’s difficult to scale DiSC for bigger organizational initiatives. The HBDI assessment is based in the Whole Brain ® Thinking methodology, which is more than just a lens for insight about self, others and teams; it can be used for more strategic applications, such as decision-making, problem-solving, delegating, creative and strategic thinking, and many other areas.

Many organizations use Whole Brain ® Thinking and the HBDI as a foundation for changing culture because Whole Brain ® Thinking provides a framework and roadmap to create a common language. This common language can be the basis for all the important business conversations we need to tackle—not just people issues, but issues of process, profit and possibilities as well.

In terms of application, with any assessment this can be a challenge. Getting people to create a new practice or behavior based on insight from any tool requires attention, focus and keeping the learning in the forefront of people’s busy days. But I have found it’s less challenging when you have a methodology that frames the concepts. Whole Brain ® Thinking gives you a language, method and framework for thinking about the world around you. It provides an organizing principle for understanding and addressing different kinds of interpersonal or business challenges. And the HBDI gives you the insight to understand yourself and others, in addition to a framework for analyzing, defining and applying shifts and changes in your thinking—and, by extension, behavior. For these reasons, Whole Brain ® Thinking and the HBDI are often more appealing to organizations that want to directly link the strategic work that talent management, L&D, OD or HR is doing with tangible business outcomes.

Tips for Using Both the HBDI and DiSC Assessment

Because DiSC is a nice entry point, you may want to use it to get a short-term, tactical implementation off the ground. But what if you decide to move to a more strategic initiative using Whole Brain ® Thinking and the HBDI down the road? Can the HBDI and DiSC coexist?

Absolutely, but there are a few things to keep in mind:

  • Understand that the HBDI is a different type of assessment, and it measures thinking preferences as opposed to the behavioral style that DiSC measures.
  • Be aware that there could be some confusion if you use them together because both models use colors as identifiers (e.g., the color blue means different things).
  • Be explicit upfront with participants about the differences and why you are using one or the other.
  • Encourage participants to look at the patterns of similarity between the two profiles. Have them review the language and descriptors of preferences and behaviors.

In my experience, participants who’ve already taken DiSC are very quick to pick up the HBDI and begin making their own comparisons. They typically find value in both tools and appreciate the distinctions, and they can begin to see, define and act on what can be done for greater efficiency, effectiveness and impact.

The four-color, four-quadrant graphic, HBDI® and Whole Brain® are trademarks of Herrmann Global, LLC.

Bring Your Whole Brain® to Work with Our Weekly LinkedIn Newsletter